Part 2: Council Weighs Dark Sky Vision, Public Safety, and Long-Term Costs - 10/09/2025

South Shore and Athol Wards

Councillors representing or closely connected to the South Shore and Athol areas generally showed strong support for exploring the Dark Sky concept. Mayor Steve Ferguson, Councillor Roberts, Councillor McNaughton, and Councillor Maynard spoke positively about environmental protection, tourism potential, and responsible long-term planning.

© PEC Council (YouTube)

View the entire PEC Council Meeting; or view our recap>

For residents in these areas, the outcome means no immediate restrictions, but staff will now study what a designation could realistically look like. Property owners are not being told to change lighting today. Any future recommendations will come back to Council for debate.

Councillors Expressing Reservations

Councillor Nyman, Councillor Harrison, and Councillor Pinnell raised concerns focused on costs, enforcement, property rights, and over-regulation. Their comments reflected rural perspectives where residents worry about added rules and financial pressure.

For constituents in these wards, it is important to note that these councillors did not oppose receiving information, but consistently pushed back against rushing into bylaws or new obligations. Their influence resulted in a study-first approach rather than immediate action.

Fire and Emergency Services Impact County-Wide

On the fire radio system, support crossed ward boundaries. Councillors from across the County agreed that firefighter safety affects everyone, regardless of location. The vote to move this into the budget process signals that emergency communications are a County-wide priority, though final funding decisions are still ahead. Residents should expect this issue to resurface during budget talks, especially as costs and tower locations are refined.

Fees and Charges Impact by Community Type

Urban and village-based councillors tended to emphasize fairness and comparisons with neighboring municipalities, while rural councillors focused on accessibility and community use of halls. The final vote reflects a compromise that preserves free access for community groups while asking private users to cover more of the true cost. For residents hosting private events, rental fees will rise modestly. For community groups, nothing changes.

Asset Management and the Big Picture

On the Asset Management Plan, support was nearly unanimous, though concerns varied. Councillor Hirsch, Councillor St Jean, Councillor Roberts, and Mayor Ferguson framed the plan as unavoidable if the County wants safe roads, functioning buildings, and reliable services.

Councillor Pinnell and Councillor Harrison voiced strong caution about affordability, fixed incomes, and the risk of pricing residents out of the County. Their comments highlight that how this plan is implemented matters just as much as the plan itself.

For residents across Prince Edward County, this vote means the County now has a clear roadmap, but taxes, service levels, and facility closures are still political decisions that will be debated annually.

---

Disclaimer: This article is based on a meeting with an approximate duration of 3:17:003. Due to the length of the meeting, our team was not able to independently review the full recording in its entirety. As a result, we relied on software-generated transcription, automated summarization, and automated recognition of speakers and participants, which may not be entirely accurate. All transcriptions, summaries, and related content are prepared by our team in good faith and on a reasonable best-efforts basis. The content is provided for general informational purposes only and is intended to support public understanding of the topics discussed. While reasonable efforts have been made to present the information accurately, automated processes may result in errors, omissions, or unintended misinterpretations. This article does not constitute an official, certified, or verbatim record of the meeting, and it should not be relied upon as such. Readers are encouraged to consult original source materials, official minutes, or recordings where available for confirmation or clarification. Questions, requests for clarification, or suggested corrections may be submitted to hello@pecconnect.ca for review and consideration.